Cinnamon, spice and everything nice—that’s what you’ll find in this warming cider punch from Chicago barman Stephen Cole. “Clove and cinnamon are natural flavors for the holiday season,” he says, “and the Angostura bitters, apple cider and sweet vermouth really echo those notes.” Best of all, it’s simple and fuss-free—just combine all the ingredients in a crock pot, heat and serve for easy holiday entertaining.